Increase Your Ecommerce Store’s Revenue with “Buy Now, Pay Later”

Hello! Jeremy Friedland from Build Grow Scale here. I’m a Revenue Optimization™ expert and also one of the lead trainers for Ecommerce Business Blueprint, an awesome training on how to build a new ecom store and brand from the ground up. In today’s video, we’re going to talk about “Buy

Matthew Stafford

Founder, BGS

12 min read

Table of Contents

https://youtu.be/ZTjNRy9z6hk

Hello! Jeremy Friedland from Build Grow Scale here. I’m a Revenue Optimization™ expert and also one of the lead trainers for Ecommerce Business Blueprint, an awesome training on how to build a new ecom store and brand from the ground up.

In today’s video, we’re going to talk about “Buy now, pay later” (BNPL) options for your store and how they can benefit your bottom line.

Not Just for Expensive Products

A lot of people think BNPL is typically reserved for higher-end products … which is true in some cases, but I’ve also seen it benefit lower-end products like print-on-demand t-shirts, mugs, and stuff like that. No matter the demographic, people will always prefer to pay over time if they can. And if it comes down to them either bouncing from your site or paying a monthly payment, they will choose the monthly payment if they love the product.

So, if you’re not offering “Buy now, pay later” currently, I’m going to give you some options to choose from—there are a lot of them out there—to help you implement it on your ecommerce store. I highly encourage you to do so no matter what price point your products are, because there are people out there who want to pay for a $33 t-shirt over multiple payments. And if you can help them buy your product and make them feel good about it, they’ll come back and continue to purchase from you. 

Pro: Skip the Liability

The biggest benefit of using BNPL apps or services is that they take on the liability if a customer chooses not to fulfill all of their payments. So, if someone buys something from your store, chooses to buy now and pay later, and then after two payments decides they’re not going to pay anymore, the BNPL company will actually go after them for the money they owe.

The only caveat to that is if you didn’t deliver the product or the customer never received it, that onus is going to be on you. But if you have an ecom store and want to stay in business, you’re probably delivering the products your customers order, in which case, BNPL is a win-win for all parties.

Con: Higher Service Fee

Now, there is a downside to the “Buy now, pay later” option, and that’s that the app or service fee is usually pretty high, which cuts into your margins quite a bit. But, like I mentioned above, you get the benefit of them going after the customer if they stop paying, so the companies offset those liability costs by charging you more for the service. Different companies charge different fees, but it’s often something like $0.30 plus a percentage of the sale, which is typically somewhere in the 7-8% range (although some go as low as 4%). Depending on the volume you do, you may be able to negotiate that rate a bit.

Real-Life Example

I can talk numbers and tell you how great BNPL options are all day, but I like to back up my statements with actual proof, so let’s look at some real-life data from one of our clients. This store offers “Buy now, pay later,” and I’m going to show you the following data from their Google Analytics account:

  • Number of people who click on the widget to view more about the BNPL program
  • How they buy
  • Total number of purchases made via the BNPL option

So, let’s dive in!

Google Analytics

Now, one really important thing I want to mention first is that if you’re not using Google Tag Manager (GTM) to track the actions on your website, I highly recommend implementing it right away. Get a developer to do that for you and start tagging all of the events that happen on your site so you know how your users’ behavior affects your website’s revenue. That’s how I was able to set up tags to see what actions people take after they click on this store’s Klarna (BNPL app) banners.

So, below is the Google Analytics account for this client, and you’ll see that we’re on the “Events” tab (“Behavior” > “Events”) in the left-hand navigation menu.

Google analytics events tab

Under the “Events” tab I have “Klarna Product Page” and “Klarna Banner.” There’s a banner on the site that shows up and people click on that, but the majority of the action happens on the Klarna product page widget. Underneath the description, I have a widget that tells the customer the item is going to cost four payments of $99, or four payments of $24.99, or whatever it is. The app automatically adjusts the payments according to the product that they’re looking at. You’ll notice this particular store has gotten 866 total events year to date. 

So, let’s go ahead and click on the “Klarna Product Page” event, and then on the “Ecommerce”’ tab to see what kind of sales this store is getting.

Klarna product page event in GA

 

You can see they’ve gotten 717 sessions, which means 717 people have clicked to learn more about the BNPL option. Out of that, there have been 84 transactions resulting in $34,654 in revenue.

The cool thing is that this is an 11.72% percent conversion rate (almost 12% of people that click on this option take it), which is approximately five times the average conversion rate for this store. That’s huge! So, the BNPL option brought in $34,654, which is about 7.5% of their average revenue. 

Shopify Analytics

Now, when we dive into the Shopify analytics, we can see that “Slice it pay over time” (a Klarna payment method) has made nearly $58,000 in total sales over 166 transactions. So, instead of $34,654, we’re talking about $23,000 more sales overall, which equals about 12% of their total revenue and an almost 12% conversion rate, just by offering the option to pay over time.

Shopify analytics of slice it pay over time

Wrap-up

As you can see from the information and example presented in this article, providing a “Buy now, pay later” option on your ecom store is insanely valuable, and something you should be doing (if you’re not, implement it today). It helps your customers afford the products they want, allows you to make a sale, and the BNPL company makes a commission to boot. Not only that, but it’s free to add the app to your store. You only get charged the commission fee when someone makes a purchase. So, it truly is a win-win-win situation and is sure to add some impressive revenue to your bottom line.

That’s the training for today, I hope you enjoyed it! And if you’d like to hear more about what Build Grow Scale does or you’re interested in finding out how we can help you build, grow, or scale your ecommerce business, go to workwithbgs.com and schedule a free strategy session with one of our Revenue Optimization™ experts. We’d love to hear from you!

Get Profit-Compounding Insights

Actionable ecommerce insights to help you scale smarter and increase profit—sent only when they’re truly worth sending.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Most Popular

Ready to Compound?

Discover your #1 growth constraint in 15 minutes

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to build profit-compounding infrastructure?

For most brands, we install the foundational infrastructure in 6-12 months. However, you’ll see measurable improvements within the first 90 days as we address your primary constraint. The key is that infrastructure continues to compound—the longer it’s in place, the more powerful it becomes.

Agencies execute tactics. We build systems. Agencies optimize campaigns. We install infrastructure. When an agency leaves, performance often craters. When our infrastructure is in place, your growth becomes self-sustaining. We embed operators who become part of your team, not external vendors managing you from a distance.

Our ideal clients are typically doing $2M-$50M in annual revenue. Below $2M, you’re often better served focusing on product-market fit and basic execution. Above that threshold, infrastructure becomes the primary growth lever. That said, every business is different—take our free diagnostic to see if we’re a fit.

Perfect. We don’t replace your team—we make them dramatically more effective. Our infrastructure integrates with your existing operations, adding the systems, data, and frameworks that turn good operators into exceptional ones. Many of our best results come from brands who already had talented teams but lacked the infrastructure to compound their efforts.

Take our 15-minute diagnostic. It identifies your #1 constraint—whether that’s infrastructure, execution, or something else. If you can’t predict revenue within 30%, if growth feels like gambling, or if you’re constantly firefighting instead of building, infrastructure is likely your constraint.

Continue Learning

More profit-compounding insights to accelerate your growth

Listen to the episode: In this powerful episode on The Edward Show, host Edward Sturm speaks with Matt Stafford, Managing Partner at Build Grow Scale, as he shares quick, actionable, and proven conversion rate optimization (CRO) hacks drawn from his decade-long experience helping hundreds of online businesses significantly boost revenue. Matt emphasizes simple but powerful […]

Listen to the episode: In this episode of the eCommerce Marketing Podcast, host Arlen Robinson has an insightful conversation with Matthew Stafford, CEO and Managing Partner of Build Grow Scale. Matthew draws on decades of entrepreneurial expertise, sharing proven strategies to significantly increase eCommerce sales through powerful, psychology-driven optimization techniques. He reveals practical insights gained […]

Listen to the episode: In this episode of the Sales Pop podcast, host John Golden speaks with Matthew Stafford, Managing Partner at Build Grow Scale, as he shares proven strategies for growing and scaling eCommerce brands by enhancing customer experience and maximizing conversions. Matthew’s extensive entrepreneurial background – spanning traditional businesses, SaaS ventures, and eCommerce […]

Stop Treating Growth Like a Gamble

Install Your Profit-Compounding Engine

Take our 15-minute diagnostic call and discover the exact constraint blocking your compounding growth right now.

Free diagnostic call

15-minute clarity

No credit card