Why Landing Pages Don’t Work – Secrets From a Decade of A/B Testing – Matthew Stafford

Listen to the episode: In this powerful episode on The Edward Show, host Edward Sturm speaks with Matt Stafford, Managing Partner at Build Grow Scale, as he shares quick, actionable, and proven conversion rate optimization (CRO) hacks drawn from his decade-long experience helping hundreds of online businesses significantly boost revenue.

Matthew Stafford

Founder, BGS

12 min read

Table of Contents

Listen to the episode:
  • Youtube
  • Youtube

In this powerful episode on The Edward Show, host Edward Sturm speaks with Matt Stafford, Managing Partner at Build Grow Scale, as he shares quick, actionable, and proven conversion rate optimization (CRO) hacks drawn from his decade-long experience helping hundreds of online businesses significantly boost revenue.

Matt emphasizes simple but powerful CRO tactics, grounded in human psychology, that any business owner can immediately implement no matter their product type, price range, or industry. From strategic thank-you page questions to optimizing checkout experiences, Matt uncovers the secrets behind the millions in extra revenue his clients have achieved.

Key Takeaways:

  1. #1 CRO Hack: Post-Purchase Friction Question:
    Immediately after purchase, ask customers, “What was the one thing that almost made you not buy?” Around 30% of buyers will respond, revealing friction points, confusions, or doubts they overcame. Acting on this feedback has consistently produced millions in incremental revenue.
  2. Power of Post-Purchase Surveys:
    Follow up purchases with a detailed survey (offering a small incentive like a gift card). Not only does this deliver valuable insights on marketing, competition, and customer desires, but these survey participants typically become your most loyal and valuable customers.
  3. Clarity Over Cleverness (the ‘Homer Simpson’ Principle):
    Your website should be so clear that even Homer Simpson would understand it. Avoid jargon, unclear copy, or complex messaging. Customers click away if anything isn’t instantly clear.

  4. Checkout Page Best Practices:
    • Clearly state why you’re collecting customer information (e.g., “Email required for order confirmation,” “Phone required for shipping notifications”). This significantly reduces errors and boosts abandoned cart recovery.
    • Display trust signals, such as reviews addressing common objections, a prominently displayed phone number, and customer-friendly refund policies.
  5. Optimize Your Above-the-Fold Section:
    Given that ~60% of visitors never scroll, your above-the-fold content must instantly build trust, clearly describe the product benefits, and help visitors quickly navigate. Include clear headlines, compelling bullet points, high-quality imagery, or videos demonstrating your product’s benefits.
  6. Strategic Pricing and Shipping Language:
    • Instead of “Free Shipping,” use the phrase “We Pay Shipping.” Customers recognize shipping costs money, so this simple reframe creates powerful reciprocity.
    • Regularly test price elasticity as most businesses underestimate their pricing power.
  7. Utilize Reviews Strategically:
    • Surprisingly, two-star reviews get clicked most and can convert highest if handled transparently. Demonstrating publicly that you address and resolve customer concerns builds strong trust and improves conversions.
    • Actively use reviews and user-generated content to boost confidence, trust, and sales across all stages of your funnel.

Notable Quotes:

  • “Instead of chasing more traffic, optimize your site to convert more of the visitors you already have. That’s where real growth happens.”
  • “Ask your customers, ‘What almost stopped you from buying?’ It’s a goldmine of insights that directly boosts revenue.”
  • “Make your messaging so clear that Homer Simpson would understand it. Simplicity scales; complexity fails.”
  • “Two-star reviews handled openly can actually drive higher conversions. People trust transparent businesses, not perfect ones.”

Get Profit-Compounding Insights

Actionable ecommerce insights to help you scale smarter and increase profit—sent only when they’re truly worth sending.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Most Popular

Ready to Compound?

Discover your #1 growth constraint in 30 minutes

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to build profit-compounding infrastructure?

For most brands, we install the foundational infrastructure in 6-12 months. However, you’ll see measurable improvements within the first 90 days as we address your primary constraint. The key is that infrastructure continues to compound—the longer it’s in place, the more powerful it becomes.

Agencies execute tactics. We build systems. Agencies optimize campaigns. We install infrastructure. When an agency leaves, performance often craters. When our infrastructure is in place, your growth becomes self-sustaining. We embed operators who become part of your team, not external vendors managing you from a distance.

Our ideal clients are typically doing $2M-$50M in annual revenue. Below $2M, you’re often better served focusing on product-market fit and basic execution. Above that threshold, infrastructure becomes the primary growth lever. That said, every business is different—take our free diagnostic to see if we’re a fit.

Perfect. We don’t replace your team—we make them dramatically more effective. Our infrastructure integrates with your existing operations, adding the systems, data, and frameworks that turn good operators into exceptional ones. Many of our best results come from brands who already had talented teams but lacked the infrastructure to compound their efforts.

Take our 30-minute diagnostic. It identifies your #1 constraint—whether that’s infrastructure, execution, or something else. If you can’t predict revenue within 30%, if growth feels like gambling, or if you’re constantly firefighting instead of building, infrastructure is likely your constraint.

Continue Learning

More profit-compounding insights to accelerate your growth

Listen to the episode: In this powerful episode on The Edward Show, host Edward Sturm speaks with Matt Stafford, Managing Partner at Build Grow Scale, as he shares quick, actionable, and proven conversion rate optimization (CRO) hacks drawn from his decade-long experience helping hundreds of online businesses significantly boost revenue. Matt emphasizes simple but powerful […]

Listen to the episode: In this episode of the eCommerce Marketing Podcast, host Arlen Robinson has an insightful conversation with Matthew Stafford, CEO and Managing Partner of Build Grow Scale. Matthew draws on decades of entrepreneurial expertise, sharing proven strategies to significantly increase eCommerce sales through powerful, psychology-driven optimization techniques. He reveals practical insights gained […]

Listen to the episode: In this episode of the Sales Pop podcast, host John Golden speaks with Matthew Stafford, Managing Partner at Build Grow Scale, as he shares proven strategies for growing and scaling eCommerce brands by enhancing customer experience and maximizing conversions. Matthew’s extensive entrepreneurial background – spanning traditional businesses, SaaS ventures, and eCommerce […]

Stop Treating Growth Like a Gamble

Install Your Profit-Compounding Engine

Take our 30-minute diagnostic call and discover the exact constraint blocking your compounding growth right now.

Free diagnostic call

30-minute clarity

No credit card