How to Read a Shopify Agency Proposal: Scope, Pricing and Red Flags

What a Shopify agency proposal should contain, how to read its scope, pricing and ownership terms, and the red flags to resolve before you sign.

Matthew Stafford

Founder, BGS

12 min read

Table of Contents

Short answer

A good Shopify agency proposal names exactly what will be delivered, what is excluded, who does the work, how changes are priced, how success is measured and who owns the code and accounts afterward. Read the scope and exclusions first, then the change-order and exit terms. The headline price only means something once those are clear.

Key takeaways

  • Read the exclusions and assumptions before the price; most budget surprises start there.
  • A scope written as activities (“ongoing optimization”) is weaker than one written as deliverables with acceptance criteria.
  • Check that themes and apps are bought in your store and billed to you, since a Shopify theme license is tied to the store it was purchased for.
  • Copyright in custom work does not move to you by default. Ask the agency, and your lawyer, about a written assignment of rights.
  • Give access through Shopify collaborator accounts, never your owner login.

What should a Shopify agency proposal include?

Proposals vary in length from two pages to forty, but the useful ones cover the same ground. Use this table as a checklist while you read.

Section What good looks like Red flag
Problem and goal Restates your goal in your numbers (revenue per visitor, conversion rate, launch date) Generic intro that could be sent to any store
Scope and deliverables Named pages, templates, features, integrations and reports Verbs with no objects: “optimize,” “enhance,” “support”
Exclusions and assumptions A written list of what is not included and what you must supply No exclusions at all
Team Roles, seniority, time allocation, any subcontractors “A dedicated team” with no roles
Timeline Milestones with dates and the approvals each one needs from you One end date and nothing in between
Pricing and payment Model, schedule, what triggers each payment Large upfront payment for work not yet scoped
Change control How new requests are estimated and approved “Minor changes included” with no definition
Measurement Baseline, the metric, how and when it is reported Results promised with no baseline
Ownership and access Who owns code, designs, accounts and data; how access is granted and removed Silence, or the agency holding accounts in its name
Exit Notice period, handover deliverables, final invoice Long lock-in with no termination clause

For the questions to ask the agency itself (proof of results, senior contacts, reference calls), use our vetting framework for choosing a Shopify agency. This article is about the document.

Book a call

A free 30-minute call about your store. Shopify Plus Partner, rated 5.0 from 8 reviews on Shopify’s Partner Directory.

Book a free call

How do you read the scope section?

Read scope as if you were going to hold the agency to it in six months, because you will. Two tests catch most problems.

Test 1: Is each line a deliverable or an activity? “Ongoing CRO support” is an activity; you can’t tell when it’s done. “Design, build and QA two product page tests per month, each with a written hypothesis and results report” is a deliverable. Activities aren’t always wrong in a retainer, but they should sit next to a stated output.

Test 2: Could two people read it differently? “Redesign the homepage” could mean a new hero image or a new information architecture. “New homepage design, one desktop and one mobile layout, two rounds of revisions, built in the existing theme” can’t be misread.

Tip

Then read the exclusions and assumptions line by line. This is where a proposal says what it doesn’t cover: copywriting, product photography, data migration, app costs, accessibility work, third-party integrations, post-launch support. Anything you expected that appears here, or doesn’t appear anywhere, is a cost you’ll meet later.

Finally, look for acceptance criteria. How will both sides agree a milestone is finished? A good answer names a test: the checkout works on these browsers, the redirect map covers every indexed URL, the report shows these metrics.

How do you read the pricing and payment terms?

Identify the pricing model first: fixed project, hourly, or monthly retainer. Each one places the risk of a scope change differently, and the payment terms should match. Our guide to what Shopify development costs for themes, apps and custom builds covers price ranges; here the question is what the terms commit you to.

Check these lines:

  • Payment schedule. Milestone payments tied to delivered work protect you more than a large deposit.
  • Change orders. How is a new request estimated, who approves it, and at what rate?
  • Rate after scope. Hourly work outside the fixed scope should have a stated rate.
  • Third-party costs. Apps, themes, fonts and tools should be listed separately and billed to you.

That last point matters more than it looks. Shopify bills app subscriptions on your Shopify invoice when the app charges through Shopify, every 30 days for recurring plans, and apps that charge outside Shopify don’t show up there at all. A proposal should say which apps it adds and which bill outside Shopify. Paid themes work the same way: Shopify says a purchased theme is licensed exclusively to the store where the purchase was made, and unlicensed themes don’t get support or updates. Make sure the theme is bought in your store, not installed from an agency’s copy.

Who owns the work, the accounts and the data?

Some proposals skip ownership entirely. Don’t sign one that does.

Worth knowing

Under US copyright law, the creator of a work is ordinarily its author and owner. The US Copyright Office explains that a commissioned work counts as a “work made for hire” only if it falls within nine specific categories and both parties sign a written agreement saying so. The circular’s nine categories don’t name software or website code; whether custom code could fit any of them is a question for a lawyer. A contract can instead include a written assignment of the rights to you on payment. Ask whether the proposal includes one, and have a lawyer read it; this article is not legal advice.

Access is the other half. Shopify gives Partners their own collaborator accounts, and its help center sets out the controls: collaborators don’t count toward your user limit, only Partners you share your 4-digit request code with can ask for access, and you can’t transfer store ownership to a collaborator. You can remove a collaborator account yourself; the removal is permanent, and the Partner has to send a new request to get back in. A proposal that asks for your owner login instead is a red flag.

Also check where data and tools live: GA4 properties, ad accounts, Klaviyo, the domain, code repositories. Each should be created under your company’s account, with the agency added as a user.

What are the red flags in a Shopify agency proposal?

Most of these are fixable with one email. The ones that don’t get fixed tell you something.

  1. Guaranteed results before anyone has seen your data. A credible agency can promise a process and a reporting standard. A conversion lift promised before an audit is a sales line.
  2. No baseline. If the proposal promises improvement but doesn’t state where you are now, nobody can say later whether it worked.
  3. The team is a logo. No roles, no seniority, no mention of whether work is subcontracted.
  4. Upfront payment far ahead of delivery. Especially for work described only as activities.
  5. Accounts in the agency’s name. Theme, apps, analytics, repository, or domain owned by the agency.
  6. No exit clause. A long minimum term with no termination for cause and no handover deliverables.
  7. Copy-paste signs. Another store’s name, products that aren’t yours, or goals that don’t match what you told them.

What should you send back before signing?

Turn your notes into a short reply. Agencies that want the work will answer it in writing.

  1. Please list everything excluded from this scope.
  2. Who exactly will work on our store, at what seniority, and is any work subcontracted?
  3. How are change requests estimated and approved, and at what rate?
  4. Which apps, themes and tools will we need to buy, and will they be billed to our accounts?
  5. What baseline will you measure against, and what will the monthly report show?
  6. Please add a clause assigning us the rights to custom code and designs on payment.
  7. What do we receive at handover if either side ends the engagement, and what notice is required?

Shopify’s own advice when contacting a Partner is to define your budget, timeline and expected outcomes in detail so the quote is accurate. The same detail, sent back with these questions, turns a sales document into a working agreement. If you’re weighing a freelancer’s proposal against an agency’s, our comparison of hiring a Shopify developer versus an agency covers the continuity risk.

How Build Grow Scale scopes its work

The first step with Build Grow Scale is a free 30-minute call to review your Shopify store’s data and conversion funnel, and you leave with the highest-impact fixes Build Grow Scale would start with, whether you hire it or not. Scope is set on that call. In the Ongoing CRO Partnership, every finding is scored for reach, impact, confidence and effort, and you see the 90-day plan before any code is written. The priorities list is reviewed with you before anything ships. Build Grow Scale also says it isn’t a fit for owners who want a guaranteed number before anyone has looked at the data.

FAQ

How long should a Shopify agency proposal be?

Length matters less than specificity. A three-page proposal that names deliverables, exclusions, team, milestones, change control and ownership is better than a forty-page deck of case studies with a one-line scope. If the scope section is shorter than the “about us” section, ask for a revised scope before going further.

Should a proposal include a timeline?

Yes, with milestones rather than a single end date. Each milestone should say what is delivered and what the agency needs from you to hit it, such as content, approvals or access. A timeline depends on your approvals as much as on the agency’s work, so a good proposal makes your responsibilities visible too.

Is it normal to pay a deposit?

A deposit for a fixed project is common, and it protects the agency’s scheduled time. What matters is proportion and what it’s tied to. Payments linked to delivered milestones keep both sides aligned. A large upfront payment for work described only in general terms puts all the risk on you.

Can I negotiate a Shopify agency proposal?

Yes. Scope, payment schedule, change-order rates, minimum term and ownership clauses are all normal things to negotiate. Narrowing the scope to a first phase is often easier than negotiating the rate, and it lets you judge the agency’s work before committing to the rest.

Book a call

A free 30-minute call about your store. Shopify Plus Partner, rated 5.0 from 8 reviews on Shopify’s Partner Directory.

Book a free call

Sources

Get Profit-Compounding Insights

Actionable ecommerce insights to help you scale smarter and increase profit—sent only when they’re truly worth sending.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Most Popular

Ready to Grow?

Take our 2-min AI Store Analysis for FREE! Powered our BGS Intelligence Hub.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to build profit-compounding infrastructure?

For most brands, we install the foundational infrastructure in 6-12 months. However, you’ll see measurable improvements within the first 90 days as we address your primary constraint. The key is that infrastructure continues to compound—the longer it’s in place, the more powerful it becomes.

Agencies execute tactics. We build systems. Agencies optimize campaigns. We install infrastructure. When an agency leaves, performance often craters. When our infrastructure is in place, your growth becomes self-sustaining. We embed operators who become part of your team, not external vendors managing you from a distance.

Our ideal clients are typically doing $2M-$50M in annual revenue. Below $2M, you’re often better served focusing on product-market fit and basic execution. Above that threshold, infrastructure becomes the primary growth lever. That said, every business is different—take our free diagnostic to see if we’re a fit.

Perfect. We don’t replace your team—we make them dramatically more effective. Our infrastructure integrates with your existing operations, adding the systems, data, and frameworks that turn good operators into exceptional ones. Many of our best results come from brands who already had talented teams but lacked the infrastructure to compound their efforts.

Take our 30-minute diagnostic. It identifies your #1 constraint—whether that’s infrastructure, execution, or something else. If you can’t predict revenue within 30%, if growth feels like gambling, or if you’re constantly firefighting instead of building, infrastructure is likely your constraint.

Continue Learning

More profit-compounding insights to accelerate your growth

Ecommerce Agency vs Marketing Agency: Which Does a Shopify Brand Need?

Why Landing Pages Don’t Work: Secrets From a Decade of A/B Testing

Matthew Stafford, Managing Partner · with Edward Sturm · September 17, 2025

Quick, actionable conversion rate optimization tactics from a decade of lifting revenue for online businesses.

Is Your Agency Working? The Monthly Report to Ask For

Why Landing Pages Don’t Work: Secrets From a Decade of A/B Testing

Matthew Stafford, Managing Partner · with Edward Sturm · September 17, 2025

Quick, actionable conversion rate optimization tactics from a decade of lifting revenue for online businesses.

Shopify App Bloat: How Many Apps Is Too Many, and What They Cost You

Why Landing Pages Don’t Work: Secrets From a Decade of A/B Testing

Matthew Stafford, Managing Partner · with Edward Sturm · September 17, 2025

Quick, actionable conversion rate optimization tactics from a decade of lifting revenue for online businesses.

Stop Treating Growth Like a Gamble

Install Your Profit-Compounding Engine

Take our 30-minute diagnostic call and discover the exact constraint blocking your compounding growth right now.

Free diagnostic call

30-minute clarity

No credit card